Military Justice in Ukraine: Why Human Rights Defenders Warn Against Military Courts
An analysis by the «Pryncyp» human rights center highlights the risks of re-establishing military courts and prosecutor's offices during the war, emphasizing the importance of civilian judicial proceedings with proper specialization.
🎓EducationPhoto: Ukrainska Pravda
Key points
- The «Pryncyp» center analyzed the proposal to restore military justice.
- There is a risk of command vertical interference in judges holding military ranks.
- Experts advocate for civilian judge specialization instead of creating a parallel court system.
Discussions regarding the restoration of the military justice system in Ukraine continue against the backdrop of a full-scale war, with the issue being actively reviewed by a Temporary Special Commission of the Verkhovna Rada. The «Pryncyp» human rights center for military personnel has joined this work, analyzing the arguments for and against such reforms. The core criterion remains whether a new structure can ensure proper law enforcement and better protection of service members' rights without compromising impartiality.
Risks of Command Vertical Influence on Justice
Proponents of establishing military courts often argue that military cases should be handled by individuals with service experience, claiming civilian judges cannot fully grasp army specifics. However, lawyers warn that if judges are granted military ranks, a serious risk of dependence on the Ministry of Defence or the General Staff arises. Such judges would be bound by military regulations and the principle of command authority, creating a threat of direct interference in judicial proceedings. Furthermore, service experience varies significantly across different branches of the military and does not inherently guarantee objectivity or deep legal knowledge.
During the war, attempts to influence judicial discretion through legislative initiatives have already been observed. Specifically, bills aimed at toughening penalties for disobedience or unauthorized abandonment of a unit targeted subordinates rather than commanders. For a service member, this creates the risk that decisions will be shaped by the strict command hierarchy rather than the law and objective case circumstances.
Alternative Solution: Specialization Instead of a New System
Throughout the full-scale invasion, civilian courts have accumulated substantial practice in handling military-related cases, proving their ability to deliver balanced decisions. Where specialized knowledge is lacking, existing laws allow for engaging experts or appointing examinations. Moreover, implementing a separate military court system in current conditions would be extremely challenging due to severe staffing and organizational hurdles.
Therefore, human rights advocates support an alternative path — introducing specialization among civilian judges for offenses related to military service regulations. Deep specialized knowledge enhances the quality of rulings and strengthens public trust in the judiciary while preserving judicial independence from departmental influences.
Source Ukrainska Pravda — pravda.com.ua/news/2026/11/20/8063800/ ↗
Read next
💼EconomyThe 'Steel Hundred': 100th OMBr Launches Recruitment Campaign for Local Residents
The 100th Separate Mechanized Brigade of the Armed Forces of Ukraine is inviting specialists to join its ranks, offering service in a highly regarded military unit.
How Much Water to Drink for Healthy Blood Pressure: Cardiologists' Advice
Leading cardiologists explained how hydration levels affect blood pressure and how much fluid individuals should consume daily to maintain cardiovascular health.
Pensioners under full state care risk receiving only 25% of payments: who is affected
In Ukraine, certain categories of pensioners living in special state-run facilities receive only 25% of their assigned pension to cover housing and care costs.
Strikes on Kerch Bridge Comparable to Hitting Strategic Target in Moscow, Expert Says
Operations against the Kerch Bridge highlight the high planning capability of Ukrainian forces and flaws in Russian air defense.
💼EconomyEU Budget Tensions: Czech Republic Opposes Direct Ukraine Aid Integration
Czech Prime Minister Andrej Babiš has criticized the proposed 2028–2034 EU budget, suggesting that financial aid for Ukraine should be handled outside the common budget f…
🏙️CityDay of Mourning Declared in Tetiiv Community for Fallen Defender Serhii Petrychenko
Tetiiv community will bid farewell to defender Serhii Petrychenko on November 23. Residents are urged to form a honor corridor.